10 Best Cleansing Balms for Removing Makeup: Melt Away Even Waterproof Makeup Gently and Effectively
Cleansing balms are thick, oil-rich skincare products designed to dissolve makeup quickly and effectively. These balms start with a solid or buttery texture that transforms into oil upon contact with skin, melting away all traces of makeup—especially stubborn waterproof formulas.
Compared to wipes or micellar water, cleansing balms offer superior makeup removal. They gently break down even heavy and waterproof makeup without tugging at the skin. Plus, many are nourishing and hydrating, making cleansing a skin-friendly experience rather than an irritation. Using a balm can also reduce the disposable waste associated with wipes and cotton pads, making this an eco-friendlier choice.
Ideal for all makeup types, especially heavy and water-resistant products, cleansing balms combine effectiveness with skin care. In this guide, we review the 10 best cleansing balms for removing makeup, detail their ingredients, discuss how to use them, and provide reviews based on real makeup melting balm reviews.
What Are Cleansing Balms and How Do They Work?
Cleansing balms are a unique category of makeup removers that start as a solid or buttery product. When you apply them to dry skin, body heat causes the balm to melt into a smooth, luxurious oil.
Their formulas are rich in oils and emollients. These ingredients work together to dissolve makeup, including long-wear products and sunscreens, as well as sebum and environmental impurities.
After massaging the balm onto the skin, adding water triggers emulsification. This changes the texture into a milky fluid that rinses away easily, leaving no oily residue behind. Unlike harsh makeup removers that can strip your skin, cleansing balms clean deeply while maintaining hydration and nourishing the skin’s natural barrier.
When comparing cleansing balms vs makeup removers like micellar water or wipes, balms consistently outperform in removing waterproof makeup and heavy cosmetics. They provide thorough cleansing with a soothing feel, avoiding irritation and dryness common with wipes or alcohol-based removers.
Why Choose Cleansing Balms Over Other Makeup Removers?
Effectiveness at Removing Stubborn Waterproof Makeup
Oil-rich cleansing balms excel at breaking down waxes, silicones, and polymers found in stubborn waterproof makeup better than micellar water or makeup wipes. Their dense emollient texture penetrates and dissolves even long-wear mascaras and lipsticks, removing makeup thoroughly without harsh rubbing.
Gentleness for All Skin Types Including Sensitive Skin
Unlike wipes that tug and damage skin, cleansing balms rely on gentle massage. This less aggressive technique prevents irritation, making them ideal for delicate skin. The absence of abrasive cloths or harsh surfactants means less redness and sensitivity post-cleanse.
Skin Nourishment and Hydration
Instead of stripping oils, cleansing balms infuse skin with nourishing ingredients like plant oils and butters. These ingredients hydrate and protect the skin barrier while cleansing, so skin feels soft and supple after use—not tight or dry. For more on hydrating skincare that supports the skin barrier, see our detailed The Ordinary Hyaluronic Acid 2% + B5 With Ceramides Review.
Eco-Friendliness
Using a cleansing balm reduces dependency on single-use wipes, cotton pads, and other disposable products. This means less waste going to landfill, benefiting the environment without compromising your makeup removal routine.
Controlled, Less Messy Application
Traditional oil-based makeup removers are liquid and can be messy or drip-prone. Balm cleansers offer a solid form that melts on contact, allowing for controlled, clean application with minimal product waste.
How to Remove Makeup with Balm Cleanser – Step-by-Step Guide
Knowing how to remove makeup with balm cleanser properly makes all the difference in effectiveness and skin comfort.
- Scoop a Small Amount: Use clean fingertips or a spatula to take a pea-sized amount of balm.
- Massage onto Dry Skin: Gently massage the balm in circular motions over dry skin. Focus on areas with heavy makeup such as eyes and lips. This allows the balm to melt and dissolve makeup oils and pigments effectively. For guidance on layering skincare routines for sensitive skin after cleansing, refer to our How to Build a Skincare Routine for Sensitive Skin.
- Add Lukewarm Water to Emulsify: Splash a little lukewarm water on your face. The balm will turn milky as emulsification begins.
- Continue Massaging: Gently massage the milky balm over your face to lift away makeup and impurities further.
- Rinse Off Thoroughly: Rinse your face well with lukewarm water. Make sure no residue remains.
- Optional Double Cleanse: For a deep, fresh feel, follow with a gentle foaming cleanser. For insights on double cleansing benefits, check out Is Double Cleansing Really Necessary?
Tips for Maximum Effectiveness
- Use lukewarm water, avoiding hot water which can irritate sensitive skin.
- For waterproof mascara, a soft, damp cloth can gently wipe away residue after emulsification.
- Take your time massaging; this improves cleansing and leaves skin feeling soft.
Using a gentle makeup remover balm for sensitive skin ensures the process is soothing, protective, and effective.
Importance of Gentle Makeup Remover Balms for Sensitive Skin
Sensitive skin is prone to redness, stinging, dryness, and irritation from harsh ingredients or physical rubbing. Because of this, choosing a gentle makeup remover balm is crucial.
Gentle balms avoid aggressive surfactants that strip protective oils, instead using soothing ingredients like chamomile, oat extract, and centella asiatica to calm the skin during cleansing. Many formulations are fragrance-free or lightly scented to minimize irritation risks.
The best cleansing balms for removing makeup sensitive skin ensure that makeup is broken down with a soft, non-abrasive texture while actively nourishing and guarding the skin’s barrier. For further support on caring for sensitive skin, see our guide How to Build a Skincare Routine for Sensitive Skin.
People with reactive or fragile skin should prioritize balms labeled for sensitive skin to prevent flare-ups and maintain comfort.
Quick Comparison Table of the 10 Best Cleansing Balms for Removing Makeup
| Product Name | Price Range | Skin Type Suitability | Waterproof Makeup Friendly | Key Highlight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Banila Co Clean It Zero | $25-$35 | All skin types | Yes | Balances cleansing and hydration |
| Clinique Take The Day Off Balm | $20-$30 | Sensitive skin | Yes | Gentle formula ideal for sensitive skin |
| Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm | $30-$40 | Normal to dry skin | Excellent | Strong oil base for waterproof makeup |
| Then I Met You Living Cleansing Balm | $38–$45 | All skin types | Yes | Luxurious K-beauty inspired with antioxidant oils |
| CeraVe Hydrating Cream-To-Foam Balm | $15-$25 | Sensitive & dry skin | Yes | Ultra-soothing, calming ingredients |
| Eve Lom Cleanser | $40-$50 | All skin types | Yes | Anti-aging + melting power |
| Neutrogena Makeup Remover Balm | $10-$20 | All skin types | Moderate | Affordable, effective |
| Fresh Soy Face Cleanser Balm | $40-$50 | Dry/mature skin | Yes | Nourishing, antioxidant-rich |
| Kiehl’s Midnight Recovery Balm | $38-$40 | Combo/oily skin | Good | Oil control, waterproof-friendly |
| Heimish All Clean Balm | $15–$25 | All skin types, including sensitive | Yes | Clean, hypoallergenic formula with botanical extracts |
Selection Criteria
These cleasing balms were selected based on:
- High effectiveness at removing everyday and waterproof makeup
- Skin-friendly, gentle, and nourishing ingredients
- Suitability for sensitive skin and various skin types
- Positive makeup melting balm reviews from users
- Broad range of prices to suit different budgets
Detailed Individual Product Reviews
1. Banila Co Clean It Zero
Banila Co Clean It Zero starts as a sherbet-textured balm that melts smoothly into oil. It suits all skin types and excels at removing waterproof mascara and heavy foundation. This balm combines cleansing power with hydration, leaving skin soft and clean.
Key Ingredients:
– Papaya extract
– Acerola extract
– Vitamin C
– Shea butter
What We Like:
– Easily melts all types of makeup, especially waterproof
– Leaves skin hydrated, no greasy residue
– Lightweight texture
– Cruelty-free and eco-conscious packaging
What to Consider:
– Fruity scent may not suit fragrance-sensitive users
– Some may need extra rinsing for oily skin
This balm is a great all-rounder for those wanting an effective yet nourishing cleansing balm. It’s especially good for frequent waterproof makeup users and those who want added antioxidants.
2. Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm
Clinique’s Take The Day Off balm is fragrance-free and hypoallergenic, designed for sensitive skin types. It has a smooth, balm-to-oil texture that dissolves makeup with a gentle touch. It is highly recommended in makeup melting balm reviews for its mild yet effective cleansing.
Key Ingredients:
– Safflower seed oil
– Petrolatum
– Water (Aqua)
– Dimethicone
What We Like:
– Fragrance-free and gentle on skin
– Efficient on waterproof and stubborn makeup
– Non-greasy finish
– Dermatologist-tested for sensitive skin
What to Consider:
– Price on the higher side
– May not deeply hydrate very dry skin
Perfect for sensitive skin, this balm delivers gentle yet powerful makeup removal. Ideal for users who prioritize mild formulations without compromising cleansing strength.
3. Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm
Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm combines anti-aging benefits with powerful makeup removal. It has a buttery texture that melts into a nourishing oil, excellent for normal to dry skin needing both hydration and thorough cleansing.
Key Ingredients:
– Padina pavonica (Algae) extract
– Elderberry oil
– Starflower oil
– Vitamin E
What We Like:
– Excellent at dissolving waterproof makeup
– Anti-aging benefits alongside cleansing
– Luxurious, spa-like feel
– Hydrates and nourishes skin barrier
What to Consider:
– Higher price segment
– Strong scent might not suit sensitive noses
This cleansing balm suits those who want a multi-tasking product that removes makeup and delivers skin-firming, hydrating benefits. A great luxury option for dry and mature skin types.
4. Then I Met You Living Cleansing Balm
Then I Met You’s award-winning cleansing balm is known for its luxurious texture, vibrant color, and clean ingredients. Inspired by Korean beauty principles, it deeply cleanses while nourishing the skin.
Key Ingredients:
– Sea buckthorn oil
– Persimmon extract
– Grapeseed oil
– Olive oil
What We Like:
– Melts makeup effortlessly, including waterproof mascara
– Packed with antioxidants and nourishing oils
– Velvety texture and subtle citrus scent
– Clean formulation with no mineral oil or synthetic fragrances
What to Consider:
– On the pricier side
– Bright orange tint may transfer slightly if not rinsed well
A standout for skincare enthusiasts who want a sensorial, effective, and nourishing first cleanse. Ideal for all skin types, especially those who love K-beauty-inspired routines.
5. CeraVe Hydrating Cream-To-Foam Balm
Formulated specifically for sensitive and dry skin, CeraVe’s hydrating balm converts easily into cream and foam when emulsified. It removes makeup gently while replenishing ceramides.
Key Ingredients:
– Ceramides 1, 3, 6-II
– Hyaluronic acid
– Niacinamide
– Chamomile extract
What We Like:
– Ultra-soothing and calming ingredients
– Hydrates and supports skin barrier during cleansing
– Fragrance-free and dermatologist-tested
– Affordable for sensitive skin care
What to Consider:
– Foaming step may not suit very dry skin post-rinse
– Might require more product for heavy makeup
A trusted option for sensitive, dry skin users wanting efficient makeup removal with added hydration and barrier repair support. For more on niacinamide benefits for sensitive and oily skin, see our The Ordinary Niacinamide 10% + Zinc 1% Review.
6. Eve Lom Cleanser
Eve Lom’s iconic cleansing balm combines makeup removal with anti-aging skincare. Its unique texture melts impurities and makeup effortlessly and leaves skin glowing and soothed.
Key Ingredients:
– Clove oil
– Eucalyptus oil
– Cocoa butter
– Chamomile
What We Like:
– Strong makeup melting power including waterproof
– Luxurious spa experience texture and scent
– Anti-aging and calming properties
– Suitable for all skin types
What to Consider:
– Price premium
– Scent not for fragrance-sensitive users
Best for those looking for a luxe, multi-benefit balm that cleanses and primes the skin for anti-aging treatments.
7. Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Balm
This budget-friendly cleansing balm performs well for all skin types. It removes everyday makeup effectively, with moderate performance on waterproof products.
Key Ingredients:
– Mineral oil
– Glycerin
– Cetyl alcohol
– Fragrance
What We Like:
– Affordable and widely available
– Removes makeup quickly
– Non-greasy finish
What to Consider:
– Not ideal for heavy or very waterproof makeup
– Contains fragrance which may irritate sensitive skin
A practical choice for beginners or budget-conscious users using regular makeup, not heavy waterproof formulas. For a deeper look at this product, see our Neutrogena Makeup Remover Melting Balm Review.
8. Fresh Soy Face Cleanser Balm
Fresh’s Soy Face Cleanser Balm blends gentle cleansing with antioxidants targeted at dry or mature skin types. It melts off makeup while nurturing skin.
Key Ingredients:
– Soy proteins
– Cucumber extract
– Rosewater
– Vitamin E
What We Like:
– Very gentle and hydrating
– Antioxidant-rich formula
– Refreshing scent
– Great for dry, mature skin
What to Consider:
– Higher price
– Limited waterproof makeup removal efficiency
Ideal for those prioritizing softness, hydration and light antioxidant protection, especially mature users with light makeup routines.
9. Kiehl’s Midnight Recovery Cleansing Balm
Specially formulated for combination and oily skin, this balm controls oil while dissolving makeup. It offers a refreshing nighttime cleansing experience.
Key Ingredients:
– Evening primrose oil
– Lavender oil
– Squalane
– Vitamin E
What We Like:
– Controls oil without over-drying
– Effective on waterproof makeup
– Smooth non-greasy finish
– Pleasant herbal scent
What to Consider:
– Contains fragrance
– Price on the higher side
Perfect for oily or combo skin users wanting a calming, oil-controlling balm that removes waterproof products effectively.
10. Heimish All Clean Balm
Heimish All Clean Balm is a K-beauty favorite known for its skin-loving botanical ingredients and effective makeup removal. It starts as a sherbet-like balm that melts into a silky oil, effortlessly breaking down even waterproof makeup without irritating the skin.
Key Ingredients:
– Shea butter
– Coconut extract
– White flower complex
– Citrus herb oil
What We Like:
– Removes waterproof and heavy makeup with ease
– Mild herbal scent and soothing formula
– Hypoallergenic and free of parabens, mineral oil, and artificial colorants
– Travel-friendly packaging with included spatula
What to Consider:
– Slight scent from natural oils may not suit everyone
– May require double cleanse for acne-prone skin types
A balanced choice for all skin types, Heimish All Clean Balm is especially appealing for users seeking a clean, minimalist formula that delivers great results without breaking the bank.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What makes a cleansing balm better for removing waterproof makeup?
Cleansing balms contain oil-rich formulas that penetrate and dissolve the waxes, silicones, and polymers in waterproof makeup far more effectively than micellar water or makeup wipes. Their emollient ingredients break down the toughest products with gentle massage, erasing residue without tugging or irritation.
Can cleansing balms replace traditional makeup removers?
Yes. For most people, cleansing balms are sufficient to remove all makeup, including waterproof formulas, especially when used as the first step in a double cleanse. They offer both makeup removal and skin nourishment unlike traditional, often harsher removers.
Are cleansing balms safe for sensitive skin?
Absolutely, provided you choose formulations that are fragrance-free and enriched with soothing ingredients such as chamomile or oat extract. These gentle makeup remover balm options reduce irritation risk while effectively cleansing.
How do cleansing balms differ from oil-based makeup removers?
While both use oils to remove makeup, balms start as a solid or butter texture and melt into oil when massaged onto skin. Oil-based makeup removers are liquid from the start. Balms offer a more controlled and less messy experience but function similarly in dissolving makeup.
How often should I use a cleansing balm?
Use nightly if you wear makeup or sunscreen daily. Regular use prevents buildup, keeps skin clean, and nourished. Even on no-makeup days, a balm cleanser can gently remove impurities.
Conclusion
The 10 best cleansing balms for removing makeup offer a gentle yet highly effective way to melt away even the most stubborn waterproof makeup. These balms stand apart from other removers by nourishing and hydrating skin while providing deep cleansing power.
Suitable for all skin types—whether sensitive, oily, dry, or mature—there’s a balm formulated to meet your skincare needs and budget. From luxury anti-aging balms to budget-friendly options, the selections here cover a wide spectrum, ensuring every makeup wearer can upgrade their routine.
Try one of these gentle makeup remover balms for sensitive skin or oil-based makeup removers for waterproof makeup today to experience a cleaner, softer complexion without harsh chemicals or waste.
